Posts

Umpires Workshops & the development of umpiring in Europe

A little less conversation, a little more action please!

Elvis may well say actions speak louder than words, but here at AFL Europe, we think that it’s the talking that helps our indigenous umpires take their first tentative steps onto the field of dreams.

Australian Football in Europe has seen the number of players and their skills developing fast over the past few years. Considering the steeper learning curve involved in both learning the game and becoming an umpire at the same time, it’s not surprising that our umpiring stocks have been a little slower to develop. Through our “entry level” Level 0 course, we’ve tried to provide learning umpires and their coaches with the fundamentals and a safe learning environment.

Shane Hill, Umpires Development Manager for AFL Europe said, “I was asked a few years back to run a course for umpires at a Euro Cup. Along with a couple of others, we tried to keep it simple, focussed on the most important decisions and gave advice about the game day environment.”

Since then, AFL Europe has run a dozen of these foundational courses across Europe. The content may have been refined, but the message remains the same says Hill, “We need umpires who understand the spirit of the game and have empathy with players. By developing umpires who keep the game safe, fair and flowing, the game will benefit.”

The Level 0 focusses solely on the spirits of the laws, “risky business” and basic positional concepts.

Importantly, umpires, players and coaches all take part in this respectful and safe learning environment, for the benefit of our great game. It is in essence just a conversation about footy. The ability to share a range of perspectives – and experience – helps the group to develop confidence for umpiring, and be able to learn from mistakes in a supportive environment. It’s an environment that can also act as a springboard to further build on club/umpire activities throughout the season.

Over 100 umpires have undertaken our gateway course to Australian Football. The Level 0 is one of the pre-requisites to undertaking the Level 1 and umpiring at key AFL Europe events.

In helping our leagues to develop umpiring, we needed to address the unique European conditions. “Taking the Australian model and telling leagues ‘this is how you develop your umpires’ missed the point – it particularly assumed some inherent learning during an umpire’s formative years. So we went back to basics, including things like 9-a-side, knowing that we needed to talk about what Australian Football actually was in a theoretical sense,” states Hill. “The way our guys and girls here play the game is so different in so many little ways. It’s a thrill to see the game in a whole new light.”

Better umpires really do mean better games.

With better umpires, players are more confident to commit themselves to the ball, pick it up and as a result, dispose more effectively. We all want to see the big marks, strong tackles and long passes to a leading forward, which all benefit when players know the risk of avoidable injury is reduced by having properly trained umpires. Encouragement not only from other umpires but also senior players and coaches who have attended these courses and know how to recognise good umpiring, enables our “third team” members with the positive reinforcement that validates our love of the game. Our club leaders are potentially the most important umpiring resource we have.

Oliver Krajacic, Captain of the Austrian Avalanche had these thoughts to share, “For us Umpiring has been approached mostly the same as Footy – a couple of dedicated blokes who almost knew what they were doing, slowly but constantly improving with time.” It would be fair to say that many leagues have a similar situation locally. Krajacic goes on, “AFL Europe delivered an Umpiring Workshop last year at our home ground in Zwaring, with players from the Croatian League participating as well. For the first time we had a professional tell us not only how to interpret the Rules of the Game in a more detailed way than we ever had before, we also got valuable advice on how to conduct a game, how to position yourself when working with a second umpire and how to communicate on the ground.” The benefits to players and umpires alike were clear to Krajacic, “Apart from drastically improving our umpiring, the workshop also helped players to better adhere to the rules, play smarter and better understand an umpires decisions and the difficulties of umpiring an Aussie Rules game.”

We certainly look forward to seeing Oliver and the Austrian side at this year’s Axios Euro Cup in London, to talk more about how umpiring is developing locally.

Taking it to the next stage, the Level 1 develops further an umpire’s core skills.

In 2013, we ran our first Level 1 course in Dublin, alongside the second European championships. Nearly a dozen umpires took the theory course and, additionally some members the national squads joined our inaugural teleconference. Many umpires involved in both the theory and the teleconference went on to umpire throughout the week in a range of conditions. All involved in the Level 1 programme received on-field feedback and a post-tournament review. As a result, the AFL recognised four umpires, who received their Level 1 accreditation.

Gavin Ward, Umpires Coordinator for DAFL was one of those involved in Dublin, “the past couple of years I have been umpiring on a regular basis. I had been a retired player in Australia for many years, so I’ve really enjoyed learning another side to the game. You learn and understand the game from one perspective as a player; where in umpiring there is a need to understand the rules on a much deeper level.”  Last year, Ward took on the role of Umpires Coordinator for the DAFL, “I was asked to help build a team of umpires. I started looking into what training is available to help other umpires in the league, when I heard about the Level 1 course to be run as part of the European Championships. The preparation needed before the course and focusing on umpiring for a full week proved to be quite beneficial. There were a lot of drills, written materials and coaching during and after games. This, along with setting up a social media forum to support and recruit umpires has really helped me to move forward in my role as Umpires Coordinator.”

It’s great to hear Gavin’s feedback. Our Level 1 course is designed to give developing umpires who desire increased performance the resources and support they need to achieve their aims.

Our approach to the Level 1 is more rigorous, with the pre-requisites being completion of the Level 0 and online theory. Successful Level 1 umpires are then observed in a minimum of three matches competently umpiring to a Level 1 standard, criteria including control, position, composure, confidence, communication, consistent application of the basic laws and have a developing understanding of how to self-assess. The criteria are set down by the AFL, who has recognised our Level 1 programme.

So what happens now?

Following feedback from our umpires like Oliver and umpires coordinators like Gavin, the conversation continues. We’ve expanded our development programme this year, particularly in consideration of the remoteness of our “third team.” We’ve held several teleconferences already this year with more to come. We will also be running two Level 1 courses, one in the UK and one in Eastern Europe. A number of forums are now also available, alongside the longstanding AFL Europe Umpires Facebook page. We already have some exciting plans under discussion here at AFL Europe HQ for 2015, so stay tuned!

Want to join the conversation or invite a friend? Our forthcoming July and October teleconferences and in the remaining Level 0 and Level 1 courses still have places remaining. Registration is via Eventbrite (http://www.eventbrite.co.uk/o/afl-europe-umpires-6007970449?ref=eorgbtn) and for each, registration closes a few days before the event.

Sorry Elvis, but we’ll have a little more conversation for our third team, please!

#umpiresweek #betterumpiresmeansbettergames #thethirdteam

2014 Umpires Teleconferences

Everybody’s talkin’ at me, but I can’t hear a word they’re sayin’.

So go the famous words of Harry Nilsson. Not so for the umpires of AFL Europe, who in 2014 have so far held three regular teleconferences, with two more still to take place before the season is out. Our conversation about umpiring is gathering momentum, and always in a safe learning environment.

“It has been difficult to visit all of our umpires on a regular enough basis to give them timely and meaningful feedback,” said Shane Hill, Umpires Development Manager for AFL Europe. “The teleconference initiative seemed like a good solution, to enable our umpires to share their ideas and just have a good yak about footy and umpiring in particular.”

AFL Europe started running umpiring teleconferences alongside the European Championships of 2013, in Dublin.

In that inaugural call, both David Levens and Steve Keating were on the line from Australia as were a roomful (and yet more dialling in from around Europe) of our European umpires asking a range of questions. The key aim of the call (and the umpiring course of which it was a part) was to help those involved to become better umpires. Better umpires mean better games, and it was great to hear everyone taking the opportunity to ask as many questions of our coaches as possible.

In 2014, we’ve already held several teleconferences, with still more to come.

AFL Europe commenced this year’s series of calls in late March, with the leadership of the AFL’s National Development Manager of Umpiring, Adam Davis. Adam provided us with his thoughts about the future of umpiring development at AFL Level and development pathways. Simon Harrison provided his extensive community football experience as did Andrew Jones. Shane Hill complemented the trio by giving a flavour to AFL Europe’s umpire development plans and provided input from his umpiring experience in Australia, UK and Europe.

Our umpires have since continued the conversation with Simon, Andrew and Shane in May and June.

“It’s been really great to hear a range of experiences from our umpires in these calls,” says Hill. “Whilst we’re all based quite remotely from each other, we are all facing similar issues and all solving them in slightly different ways. By sharing the issues we face, we’ve been able to talk about possible solutions and I think this is probably the most positive way we can support our ‘third team’ members.”

During our series of calls in 2014, a wide range of topics have been discussed. The list of topics has touched on all the essentials an umpire needs to develop a mastery of the craft. Blow Show Go, common sense umpiring, protecting the ball player, prior opportunity, positioning, developing an umpiring community and seeking feedback are just some of the threads we’ve covered in over 5 hours of conversation this year.

Our umpires have really taken the opportunity to discuss umpiring in a relaxed environment amongst their peers and hopefully have benefited from their participation.

Nilss Lode, Umpires Coordinator for AFLG has been one of our regular participants. “Umpiring in the German league can be demanding when new players first start playing, as the skill level and knowledge of the rules is significantly less than experienced players. The umpires will try to explain the laws and what infringement has been paid for new players. In my role as Umpires Coordinator, my aim has been to improve overall umpiring standards.” Lode had these thoughts about our teleconferences this year, “The teleconferences run by AFL Europe have helped me to improve my confidence and consistency in decision making, by having the opportunity to ask questions about certain incidents during games.”

We thank Nilss and indeed all of our umpires who have dialled in to our teleconferences this year for their important input.

One particular benefit of our discussions this year is that a number of materials have been made available for our umpires portal on the AFL Europe webpage. Your one-stop umpiring shop can be found at http://afleurope.org/be-involved/umpire/. In the coming weeks, you’ll see resources posted here to help you develop as an umpire, and for Umpires’ Coordinators use in their coaching. We welcome your feedback as we develop these resources for you, our umpires.

Do you want to join in the umpiring conversation?

Our next teleconference is set for Wednesday 23rd July at 8pm (UK time) and there will be a “Season Wrap” in the week after Axios Euro Cup. If you want to join the conversation then register via Eventbrite, at: http://www.eventbrite.co.uk/o/afl-europe-umpires-6007970449?ref=eorgbtn. Dialling details are provided to all registered attendees.

If you have further questions about our teleconferences, or if you would like to know more about umpiring where you are, contact umpires@afleurope.org.

#umpiresweek #betterumpiresmeansbettergames #thethirdteam

Picture by Derek Clarke